Iron Goo
Manufacturing company owner reviews a ten-item checklist beside two proposals above the workshop floor

How to Choose an SEO Consultant

Atamyrat Hangeldiyev
Atamyrat Hangeldiyev
Systems Architect
SEO
Table of contents
  1. 1. They ask about your business first
  2. 2. What will the audit estimate?
  3. 3. The people and hours behind the work
  4. 4. Will you see every change and its reasoning?
  5. 5. What source supports each recommendation?
  6. 6. Expected results, timeframe, and measurement
  7. 7. The promises they refuse to make
  8. 8. How links are earned, and whether they want one from you
  9. 9. What is their AEO or GEO advice?
  10. 10. Who owns the accounts, and how do you leave?

An SEO consultant is on your calendar, two or three proposals are open, and you need to decide which promises deserve a second look. For how to choose an SEO consultant, start with a question most older checklists miss: can the consultant cite official Google documentation for each recommendation? Google rewrote its SEO hiring advice on 5 June 2026 and added that question.

The ten checks
  1. Did the consultant ask about your business?
  2. What will the audit estimate?
  3. Who does and implements the work, and for how many hours?
  4. Will you see every change and its reasoning?
  5. What evidence supports each recommendation?
  6. What results are expected, when, and how are they measured?
  7. What will the consultant refuse to promise?
  8. How are links earned, and is a link from you required?
  9. What does the consultant recommend for AEO or GEO?
  10. Who owns the accounts and domains, and how do you leave?

1. They ask about your business first

An SEO consultant needs to understand your business before proposing work that serves it. Google's hiring page says your SEO should ask what makes your company unique, who your competitors are, how search results can help, and how customers find you. Google also recommends checking references and asking past clients whether the work was useful.

A proposal can outline an initial audit before the consultant knows every detail. A fixed list of changes presented without questions about your customers or commercial priorities deserves more scrutiny. Ask the consultant which parts of the proposal would change after an audit and which assumptions it relies on.

Good answer: “Before I recommend pages or a schedule, tell me which services you want to sell, who buys them, and how people find you now. The audit will test the assumptions in this proposal.”

Red flag: “I already know what your business needs. We use the same package for every company in your industry.”

2. What will the audit estimate?

An SEO audit should give you a realistic estimate of possible improvement and an estimate of the work involved. Google's hiring advice names both outcomes and warns against a first-place guarantee. Ask what the written deliverable will contain and whether its work estimate separates recommendations from implementation.

An estimate is a planning tool, not a promise that Google will produce a particular result. You should be able to see the proposed work, the assumptions behind the expected improvement, and what the consultant would need to learn before narrowing either estimate. Ask whether the audit stands on its own if you decide not to buy ongoing work.

Good answer: “You will get a written assessment with the opportunities I can identify, a realistic estimate of potential improvement, and an estimate of the work. I will label assumptions and explain what I cannot establish from the available data.”

Red flag: “The audit guarantees we can get you to first place. We will discuss the work after you sign the ongoing contract.”

3. The people and hours behind the work

An SEO proposal needs a named person or role for implementation as well as advice. The version of Google's hiring page before June 2026 explicitly told buyers to be committed to implementing recommendations, a line removed from the current page. The practical question remains: who has the time and permission to make the proposed changes?

A consultant who advises and an agency or freelancer who implements are different purchases, so ask which one the proposal describes. Use the SEO pricing breakdown to convert a quote into monthly hours; in my view, roughly eight skilled hours a month is the floor for a retainer aimed at substantive page work. Whether to hire a freelancer, an agency, or an in-house SEO expert is a separate decision.

Good answer: “I will audit and advise for a stated number of hours each month. Your developer will implement the site changes, and we have included time to review that work.”

Red flag: “Implementation will sort itself out. We do not assign hours or say who makes changes until after you sign.”

4. Will you see every change and its reasoning?

A change record lets you assess what an SEO consultant did to a site and why. Google's interview questions ask whether the SEO will share all site changes and provide detailed information about the recommendations and their reasoning. Google also cautions against companies that are secretive about what they intend to do.

Ask to see the format before signing: a shared record should identify the page, the change, the person responsible, and the reason. Agree on which changes need your approval before publication. That gives your team something concrete to review when a recommendation affects a service description or a page that customers use.

Good answer: “You will receive a change log with the affected pages and reasons. We will agree on approval for changes before they go live, and you can keep the record after the engagement.”

Red flag: “Our process is proprietary, so we cannot show you what we change. You will see the outcome in our monthly score.”

5. What source supports each recommendation?

An SEO recommendation should cite official Google documentation or identify itself as an opinion supported by data or experience. Google's 5 June 2026 change log says the hiring page gained guidance on evaluating recommendations and tools. The current page asks, “Do they cite official Google documentation as supporting evidence for their recommendations?” Google's third-party guidance also allows for claims qualified as opinion based on data or experience.

Individual changes are often hypotheses. A 2020 recap of a SearchPilot webinar reported that more than half of its controlled SEO tests were inconclusive, meaning there was insufficient evidence to call an effect, not proof of no effect. Ask which recommendations have direct documentation and which depend on the consultant's interpretation.

Good answer: “Here is Google's guidance for this recommendation. For the other change, my view is based on these observations; I cannot promise the same effect on your site.”

Red flag: “Google says this always works, but I cannot show you where. Our tool confirms it.”

6. Expected results, timeframe, and measurement

An SEO forecast needs a proposed result, a timeframe, and a measurement source. Google's current hiring page asks, “What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?” and “How do you measure your success?” It gives no timeframe of its own. From at least January 2024 through the version before the June 2026 rewrite, Google's page said results typically took four months to a year; that is no longer its current wording.

Google says third-party tools lack access to its internal ranking data and strongly encourages using its first-party Search Console. The guide to measuring SEO and fixing traffic decay explains how to read those reports and investigate drops.

Good answer: “I expect changes in clicks and impressions for these named pages over this period, with uncertainty. We will compare Search Console data with the leads you record.”

Red flag: “Our proprietary authority score will prove success. Rank-tracker screenshots are the only report you need.”

7. The promises they refuse to make

A consultant cannot guarantee a number-one Google ranking. Google's warning also names claims of a “special relationship” with Google and “priority submit” offers as reasons for caution.

A guarantee paired with claimed Google ties has appeared in a documented deception case. In May 2018, the FTC charged Pointbreak Media, a robocall operation accused of falsely claiming to represent Google and promising first-place or first-page placement. One program offered a purported top-placement guarantee for $949.99 plus monthly payments. In May 2019, the FTC announced that a court had ordered two operators to pay $3,367,666.30. The case illustrates a deception pattern, not typical consultant behavior.

Good answer: “I can explain the work and give you an estimate, but I cannot guarantee a ranking or claim privileged access to Google.”

Red flag: “We work directly with Google, so we can guarantee first-page placement if you sign today.”

A link plan should explain how links are earned and whether your contract requires a link to the consultant. Google says, “You should never have to link to an SEO,” and warns against link popularity schemes. Its spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes, certain contractually required links, and widely distributed footer or template links as examples of link spam.

Ask what activity produces the proposed links and who decides whether to publish them. Read the contract and any proposed site footer for a required consultant credit. A package described only by the number of links leaves you unable to assess where those links come from or what you are agreeing to buy.

Good answer: “We will seek editorial coverage by offering relevant material to publishers. You do not have to link to us, and we will explain each proposed outreach activity.”

Red flag: “Our monthly link package supplies placements, and your contract requires a footer link to our site.”

9. What is their AEO or GEO advice?

Google treats optimization for generative AI search as SEO for the Google Search experience. Its generative AI optimization guidance says that, for Google Search, you can ignore tactics such as content “chunking,” unnecessary AI text files such as llms.txt, and inauthentic mentions. Google also says no special schema.org markup is required for generative AI search.

That guidance applies to Google Search; it does not establish rules for other assistants. Ask what a separate AEO or GEO proposal would actually add to the SEO work and which claims come from Google. The guide to SEO for AI search and AEO covers how AI search selects and cites pages.

Good answer: “For Google Search, I will follow its generative AI guidance. If I recommend work for another assistant, I will explain the evidence and label any assumptions.”

Red flag: “You need our separate AEO package with llms.txt, chunking, and special AI schema to appear in Google's AI results.”

10. Who owns the accounts, and how do you leave?

Account ownership and an exit plan determine whether your company can retain control after an SEO engagement. For an audit, Google says to “only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access).” Search Console distinguishes a verified owner, who verifies ownership with a token, from a delegated owner, a full user, and a restricted user. A full user can take some actions; a restricted user has view rights to most data. Search Console's permissions documentation explains each role.

Open key cabinet with an amber owner key, two cyan user keys, and scissors cutting a token tag from a chain

The company keeps the owner key, while the consultant receives access suited to the task. At exit, remove the user and any verification token the consultant placed.

For later work, my recommendation is to grant only the access a specific task requires. At exit, remove the user and delete any verification tokens they placed: Google says a deleted owner can re-verify while their token remains. Your company should retain verified ownership.

A Business Profile has one primary owner; a manager cannot add or remove users or remove the profile. Keep your company as primary owner and give the consultant manager access when needed. Keep domains and hosting in company accounts too. Google's page before June 2026 warned that an SEO could own a shadow domain and point it elsewhere if the relationship soured; that example was removed from the current page.

Good answer: “You own the accounts and domains. I will request read access for the audit, specify any later permissions by task, and document how to remove my access and tokens.”

Red flag: “Make me an owner before I start, and I will register the domains in my account. We can discuss access when you leave.”

Google says you are ultimately responsible for the actions of companies you hire. My decision rule is to get written answers to checks 2, 5, and 10 before the first invoice: the audit estimate, the source or opinion standard, and the ownership and exit plan. A ranking guarantee, a claimed special relationship with Google, or a request for owner access before work starts ends the conversation.

You can put the same ten checks to Iron Goo's SEO service. Ask us to answer them in writing before you decide.

Free ebook

Put your next steps in order

Build on what you have just read with a free ebook on semantic SEO and AI visibility. Get worked examples, decision rules, checklists and a do-this-week action in every chapter, plus a six-week plan for your site.

By signing up and confirming your address, you consent to receive the free ebook plus one email every two weeks with 3 or 4 new Iron Goo videos, guides and articles, and nothing else; unsubscribe any time with one click.

More posts